Baby Sleep Central

the baby sleep industry, reviewed from the inside

Sleep Methods

The No-Cry Sleep Solution Review: Pantley's Gentle Plan

The No-Cry Sleep Solution reviewed by a sleep consultant: Pantley’s sleep logs, the Gentle Removal Plan, honest timelines and the safe-sleep line to keep.

The No-Cry Sleep Solution Review: Pantley's Gentle Plan

The No-Cry Sleep Solution is Elizabeth Pantley’s book for parents who want better nights without leaving their baby to cry. Its plan has three parts: keep sleep logs, choose a few gentle changes from a menu, and review the logs after ten days. Its best-known tool is the Gentle Removal Plan, a way to ease a baby off nursing or a bottle to sleep. Does it work? For a patient family whose main problem is a sleep association, often yes, slowly. It is not a quick fix, and “no-cry” means less crying, not none.

I make my living in this industry, and roughly half the families who contact me have already ruled out crying-based training. This is one of the books I point them to. Below is what it does well, where it is weaker, and the one safety line I would add to any copy.

What the book is

The current edition is The No-Cry Sleep Solution, Second Edition, published by McGraw-Hill Education. The original Gentle Ways to Help Your Baby Sleep Through the Night edition, first published in 2002, is still sold, and its enhanced ebook carries a foreword by William Sears, M.D., according to its Amazon listing. Pantley later wrote spin-offs, including The No-Cry Sleep Solution for Newborns and The No-Cry Sleep Solution for Toddlers and Preschoolers. If your child is past babyhood, the toddler book is the closer fit.

The old nocrysolution.com address now redirects to Pantley’s fiction site (a cozy-mystery series, checked 2026-11-15), so there is no vendor page to check claims against. Everything below comes from published summaries and reader reviews of the book.

How the plan works

Shortform’s summary of the book describes the order of work: first “understanding your baby’s unique sleep cycles and habits through meticulous tracking”, then “creating a tailored, consistent bedtime routine to foster independent sleep while providing comfort”, with adjustments for “teething, illness, and multiples”.

A parent reviewer at ResearchParent adds the rhythm: “There are logs that one is supposed to fill out every 10 days.” In practice that means:

StepWhat you doWhat it is for
LogRecord bedtime, every night waking, feeds and napsSee the real pattern, not the one you remember at 3am
ChoosePick a small number of changes from the book’s menuFix the problem you have, not every problem at once
Run the planApply the changes consistently for ten daysGive gentle changes time to work
ReviewLog again and compareDecide what to keep, change or drop

The logging is the strongest part of the book. In consults, the pattern I see is parents who are sure their baby wakes “every hour” and whose log shows four wakings with one long stretch they had forgotten. You cannot fix a pattern you have not written down.

The Gentle Removal Plan

This is the part of the book most parents remember. Shortform describes it as watching your baby during a feed and, when sucking slows and your baby gets drowsy, gently removing the nipple, using gentle support at the cheek, soft touch and quiet words to help your baby settle without going back to the breast or bottle. You repeat it, a little earlier each time, until your baby can fall asleep without feeding.

It is a good tool for one specific problem: a baby who can only fall asleep while feeding. It is slow, and expect protest on some attempts, because a gentle method still changes something your baby likes. If feeding to sleep is your main issue, my guide to stopping feeding to sleep sets out the other options beside this one.

Two cautions. First, a baby who wakes to feed because they are hungry needs the feed, not a removal plan. Whether night feeds can be reduced is your pediatrician’s call. Second, if your baby has reflux, a feeding difficulty or weight concerns, talk to your pediatrician before changing how feeds end. Shortform notes that Pantley herself discusses reflux, sensitivities and breathing problems as reasons to involve “healthcare experts”, which I agree with.

The safe-sleep line to keep beside it

Some families who choose a no-cry plan also share a bed; the ResearchParent reviewer co-slept with both of her children. Whatever any book says about sleeping arrangements, the American Academy of Pediatrics is clear. Its parent’s guide to safe sleep recommends room sharing “close to your bed—but not in the same bed” for at least the first six months.

It also says that if you bring your baby into your bed to feed or comfort them, “place them back in their own sleep space before you go to sleep”. So run the Gentle Removal Plan in a chair or on the edge of your bed, then lay your baby on their back in a bare crib or bassinet. No method’s gentleness changes that.

What the book does well

  • It starts with evidence from your own home. Ten days of logs before and after is a better test than any feeling.
  • It treats parents as decision-makers. You choose from a menu rather than following a script.
  • It is honest that progress is gradual. The ten-day review sets that expectation from the start.
  • It covers the hard weeks. Teething, illness and growth spurts are planned for, not treated as failure.

Where it is weaker

  • Speed. The ResearchParent reviewer, who liked the book’s respect for the child, wrote that it is “so respectful that I’m not actually sure it can be much more effective than doing nothing”, and reported that the author herself expects change “over a period of a couple weeks or months”. Gentle methods trade crying for time. My no-cry methods page sets out realistic timelines, and they run to weeks.
  • A menu can be too long. Parents who try every suggestion at once cannot tell which one worked. Pick two or three.
  • Little research behind the specific steps. The book is a parent author’s practical plan. The method with the best evidence in the gentle family is bedtime fading, which my fading method review covers.
  • It cannot fix medical problems. Snoring, laboured breathing or poor weight gain is a pediatrician conversation, full stop.

The free version of this advice

  1. Keep a log for ten days before changing anything: bedtime, wakings, feeds and naps.
  2. Pick one problem, usually falling asleep at the breast or bottle.
  3. Choose one gentle change for it, such as ending the feed a little earlier each night and finishing settling with your hand on your baby’s chest.
  4. Keep the same calm bedtime routine every night.
  5. Log for another ten days and compare.

That is the book’s core plan for nothing. The book is worth buying if you want Pantley’s full menu of ideas and the reassurance of a whole volume on gentle sleep. It costs less than a single consultant call.

Who it suits, and who should skip it

Your situationMy view
Feeding to sleep is the main problemA good fit. Start with the Gentle Removal Plan
You will not use any crying-based methodA good fit, if you can give it weeks
You need change within a weekGraduated check-ins are faster; see my comparison of sleep-training methods
Your child is a toddlerChoose the toddler edition instead
There is a medical question about sleep or feedingSee your pediatrician first

What I’d tell a client

If you have ruled out crying and your baby can only fall asleep while feeding, buy this book or borrow it, and start with the logs and the Gentle Removal Plan. Give it a full ten days before judging it, and change only two or three things. Keep your baby’s sleep space separate from your bed. If you are still exhausted after a month of real consistency, a faster method is not a failure. It is a different trade.

FAQ: The No-Cry Sleep Solution

What is the Gentle Removal Plan?

It is Elizabeth Pantley’s way of ending feeding to sleep. As your baby’s sucking slows, you gently remove the nipple and help them settle with touch and quiet words, a little earlier each time.

Does The No-Cry Sleep Solution really involve no crying?

Less crying, not none. Babies often protest any change. The method keeps you with your baby and responding, which is what most families mean by no-cry.

How long does The No-Cry Sleep Solution take?

The book works in ten-day blocks: log, run the plan, then review. Many families need more than one block to see a real change.

Is The No-Cry Sleep Solution safe for co-sleeping families?

The method itself is gentle, but the AAP recommends room sharing without bed sharing for at least the first six months. Settle your baby in their own crib or bassinet, on their back, before you go to sleep.

Which edition should I buy?

For a baby, the second edition of the original book. For a newborn, the newborn edition. For a child past about age one, the toddler and preschooler edition.

More in the Sleep Methods file.

Margot Finch, Baby Sleep Central author

The consultant on call

Margot Finch

I'm Margot — a working pediatric sleep consultant and mom of two, several years into client work that runs from newborn nights to toddler curtain-calls. I make my living in this industry, which is exactly why I review it honestly: what the methods, apps, courses and consultants can actually do, what they can't, and the free version of the advice they're selling. In consults, the pattern I see is families who spent hundreds before anyone told them the whole picture. This site is the whole picture. Medical questions always go to your pediatrician first — that's not fine print, that's the method.

More about Margot