Baby Sleep Central

the baby sleep industry, reviewed from the inside

Sleep Methods

The Baby Whisperer Review: E.A.S.Y. and Pick Up Put Down

A sleep consultant reviews Secrets of the Baby Whisperer: the E.A.S.Y. routine, pick up put down, where its feeding times clash with the AAP and who it suits.

The Baby Whisperer Review: E.A.S.Y. and Pick Up Put Down

Secrets of the Baby Whisperer is a 2001 baby-care book by Tracy Hogg, written with Melinda Blau, and it is the origin of two ideas most parents meet without her name attached: the E.A.S.Y. routine (eat, activity, sleep, you) and pick up put down. Is it worth reading? For a parent who wants a flexible daytime rhythm and a gentle settling method, yes, as long as you treat its feeding timings as a rough guide. Where they pull against feeding on cues, the American Academy of Pediatrics wins, and so does your pediatrician.

I make my living in this industry, and I have no tie to the book or its publisher. This review covers the book itself. The technique and the routine have their own pages, linked below, so I will not repeat them here.

Who Tracy Hogg was

Penguin Random House’s author page says Hogg “obtained her nursing degree in England, specializing in maternity and neonatal care”, that the nickname “the Baby Whisperer” came from her “uncanny ability to understand and calm babies”, and that in 1997 she founded Baby Technique, consulting with parents, teaching classes and training nannies. She died of melanoma in November 2004.

So the book comes from a maternity nurse and private baby consultant: someone with years of hands-on work with babies, writing from that experience rather than from research. That matters for how you read it. Her advice reads like a practitioner’s, which is a strength for practical detail and a weakness wherever it states a rule as settled fact.

Two later titles carry her name: Secrets of the Baby Whisperer for Toddlers, and The Baby Whisperer Solves All Your Problems, a troubleshooting book covering sleep, feeding and behavior from infancy into toddlerhood. If your problem is already a specific sleep or feeding struggle, that second book is the problem-solving volume.

What the book teaches

Wikipedia’s entry on the book summarises its core idea as “a flexible routine for babies, from a very early age, of eating, followed by activity, followed by sleep”, based “on the baby’s needs” rather than “a schedule dictated by the parent”.

On sleep, the same entry says Hogg wanted a baby to sleep in their own bed and learn to calm themselves “with gradually decreasing amounts of assistance from her parents”. She presented this as a middle path between the Ferber method and co-sleeping, and she “does not recommend leaving a child to ‘cry it out’ or using controlled crying”.

Three ideas do most of the work:

IdeaWhat it isWhere I cover it
E.A.S.Y.Eat, Activity, Sleep, You-time, repeated through the daythe eat-play-sleep cycle
Pick up put downLift a crying baby, calm them, lay them back down awake, repeatmy pick up put down review
Tanking up and a dream feedExtra feeds in the early evening, then a late feed given while the baby sleepsnight weaning and the dream feed

The third row comes from GoodtoKnow’s walk-through of the E.A.S.Y. routine, which describes Hogg’s “cluster feeds” of “two feeds close together before bedtime”, which she called “tanking up”, followed by a “dream feed” at 10 to 11pm. It also notes how often you repeat the cycle “will depend on how long your baby takes to eat and sleep”.

Where the feeding advice needs a pediatrician’s eye

This is the part of the book I would read with a pencil.

KellyMom’s critical review, written from a breastfeeding-support perspective, reports that E.A.S.Y. sets times for each step: eating “25 to 40 minutes every 2 ½ to 3 hours”, activity “45 minutes”, sleep “one half to one hour”, and “an hour or more for mom”. The same reviewer says Hogg “takes a couple of paragraphs to dismiss rigid schedules and on-demand feeding”, and argues the book understates the benefits of breastfeeding.

Set that against the American Academy of Pediatrics’ feeding guide on HealthyChildren. It says “Breastfed newborns usually nurse every 2 hours”, with “10-12 sessions in 24 hours” the norm, and it recommends “feeding on demand, or responsive feeding”: watching the baby’s hunger cues rather than the clock.

A gap of two and a half to three hours is inside what the AAP describes for bottle-fed newborns (“every 2 to 3 hours”). It is longer than what it describes for many breastfed newborns. So if you are breastfeeding a young baby, read E.A.S.Y. as an order of events, not a timetable. Feed when your baby shows hunger, then play, then sleep. Any question about weight gain, supply or a sleepy feeder is a pediatrician conversation, full stop.

In consults, the pattern I see with E.A.S.Y. is not hunger. It is parents who feel they are failing because their baby will not stay awake for 45 minutes at three weeks old. The book’s flexible intent gets lost in its numbers.

Is pick up put down in the book worth trying?

Cleveland Clinic’s explainer credits the method to “nurse Tracy Hogg in her book Secrets of the Baby Whisperer” and advises against sleep training “a baby who is under 4 months old”. That age line matches mine.

My full verdict is on the pick up put down page linked above. The short version is that it works best for younger babies past that four-month line, it is hard work for the parent, and it often stops working once the lifting itself becomes stimulating for an older baby. It is a reasonable first method for a family that cannot face timed check-ins. It is not a no-cry method, because the baby cries in your arms instead of in the crib.

What has aged well and what has not

Aged well:

  • Feeding at the start of the cycle, not the end. Separating the feed from falling asleep is still one of the most useful things a parent can do for night wakings.
  • Reading your baby before reacting. The book’s emphasis on telling one cry from another holds up.
  • The “you” in E.A.S.Y. A routine that plans a break for the parent is honest about who is doing the work.
  • No cry it out. For families who will not leave a baby to cry alone, it offers a structured alternative.

Aged badly:

  • Times that look like rules. Fixed durations for feeds and play are easy to misread as targets.
  • The tone on breastfeeding. KellyMom’s criticism is fair: the book treats on-demand feeding as a problem to manage.
  • Certainty. Like most baby books of its era, it states its approach as the sensible answer rather than one option among several.

The free version of this advice

You can run the useful part of the book for nothing.

  1. When your baby wakes, offer a feed first.
  2. After the feed, keep your baby awake for a short spell of play, as long as they are content.
  3. At the first yawns or glazed looks, put your baby down drowsy, on their back in a bare crib or bassinet.
  4. Take a break of your own while they sleep.

That is E.A.S.Y. without the stopwatch. If you want a book anyway, the original Secrets of the Baby Whisperer is the one to start with. For a schedule-led book that goes further towards clock time, compare my Babywise review.

Who it suits, and who should skip it

Your situationMy view
You want a daytime rhythm and a gentle settling methodA good fit. Read it for the order of events
You are breastfeeding a newbornUse the order, not the times. Feed on cues
You want fast results and can face cryingLook at graduated check-ins instead
Your baby is under four months and you want to sleep trainWait. Neither this nor any method is meant for that age
You want the research behind each claimThis is a practitioner’s book, not a research summary

What I’d tell a client

Read it for the shape of the day, not the numbers. Feed when your baby wakes, play a little, then sleep, and take your own break when you can. Ignore the minutes if they fight your baby’s hunger, because feeding on cues comes first. If your baby is past four months and you want a gentle way to stop rocking to sleep, try pick up put down for a week before you consider anything with more crying.

FAQ: The Baby Whisperer

What does E.A.S.Y. stand for?

Eat, Activity, Sleep, and You. It is the order of a baby’s day in Tracy Hogg’s routine: feed after waking, then play, then sleep, then time for the parent.

Who wrote Secrets of the Baby Whisperer?

Tracy Hogg, an English-trained maternity nurse who worked as a private baby consultant, with co-author Melinda Blau. It was published by Ballantine Books in 2001.

Is the Baby Whisperer the same as Babywise?

No. Both put feeding at the start of the cycle, but Babywise is built more firmly around the clock. Hogg described her routine as following the baby’s needs.

Is the Baby Whisperer a cry-it-out method?

No. The book does not recommend cry it out or controlled crying. Its main settling tool is pick up put down.

What age is the Baby Whisperer book for?

The main book covers the first year. Sleep training with pick up put down should wait until at least four months, and a later book covers toddlers.

More in the Sleep Methods file.

Margot Finch, Baby Sleep Central author

The consultant on call

Margot Finch

I'm Margot — a working pediatric sleep consultant and mom of two, several years into client work that runs from newborn nights to toddler curtain-calls. I make my living in this industry, which is exactly why I review it honestly: what the methods, apps, courses and consultants can actually do, what they can't, and the free version of the advice they're selling. In consults, the pattern I see is families who spent hundreds before anyone told them the whole picture. This site is the whole picture. Medical questions always go to your pediatrician first — that's not fine print, that's the method.

More about Margot